Before one can use the help of test reports on pianos or an e-piano test, many wonder if one should rather resort to a classical piano or an electric piano (or digital piano).
Exactly this question answers this article. The pros and cons are exposed, clarified for whom one or the other should rather be considered and made a recommendation.
Piano or electric piano?
First of all, let me say to the terminology that in today’s parlance with e-piano is usually meant a digital piano (and not the well-known from the 60s and 70s electric pianos) and also in this article is the case. For that you will need to know what is the best digital piano.
The question of whether a piano or e-piano is better suited, in fact, is increasingly difficult to answer, since the digital pianos are getting better today. Many years ago, the answer was surely the piano. These days, however, it looks a bit different, as the digital pianos have many advantages over the piano.
For whom is something suitable?
For beginners who want to get an instrument for getting started, we would generally always recommend an electric piano. The low purchase price and the additional functions simply offer the greatest added value here. Thus, the new hobby can also be tried first without organizing a huge transport and disturb the roommates by loud practice.
Anyone who also takes piano lessons, anyway, is not necessarily dependent on a private piano at home, since the e-piano is completely sufficient for practicing. In the piano lessons, the student gets the feeling on the piano, which then masters both.
However, pianists who only want to play “classical” piano should think about buying a piano. In classical piano music a lot of dynamics are used and additional functions like other voices or effects are probably not interesting.
The advantages and disadvantages of the piano in short form are:
- Unadulterated, original sound
- More possibilities of expression
- Original feel
- Better for “classic” games
- Noble “living room look”
- Very high purchase costs (> 5000 €)
- Hard to transport
- Disapproves and must be tuned regularly
- Regular votes incur follow-up costs
- Even the wood can be forgiven, making the piano must be tuned more often
- Volume cannot be adjusted, which could disturb neighbors / housemates
- e-piano yamaha ydp-142b arius
- Electric piano: Yamaha YDP-142b Arius
The advantages and disadvantages of the electric piano are:
- Much cheaper
- Nevertheless, the feeling is already very close to the piano these days
- Easy to transport / move
- Volume can be adjusted and headphones can be used
- Easy to connect to the PC for recordings
- Additional functions such as voices (organ, e-piano, harp, etc.), effects (reverberation, delay, etc.) and built-in metronome
- A different piano sound can be used via the PC
- Touch / attack may differ from a real piano
- Sound depends on the quality of the recordings and the speakers
The classical piano (logically) offers the most authentic feel and a very dynamic sound through the underlying mechanics. When a string is struck, the ones next to it also swing slightly, resulting in a nice sound volume. Not only that’s why electric pianos were often not taken seriously.